Letter of Archbishop Mancini

This weekend the following letter was written by Bishop Mancini to the Catholics in Nova Scotia. It reflects the pain and agony the situation with Bishop Lahey has caused Catholics across Canada. I think we all need to read it, and then try to be still before God – seeking God’s healing grace and the courage to face this terrible challenge once again.


P.O. BOX 1527


B3J 2Y3

October 2, 2009

To the Roman Catholic Faithful of Nova Scotia,
Greetings and peace.

In the past days, I have been asked over and over again: What do you say to the
parishioners, to the priests, the young people and to the faithful communities that make up our Church in Nova Scotia? What will you say to the victims of sexual abuse, as we all struggle in the aftermath of unbelievable revelations and allegations of even more unacceptable shocking and possible criminal sexual behaviour?

What I want to say is: Enough is enough! How much more can all of us take? Like you,
my heart is broken, my mind is confused, my body hurts and I have moved in and out of a variety of feelings especially shame and frustration, fear and disappointment, along with a sense of vulnerability, and a tremendous poverty of spirit. I have cried and I have silently screamed, and perhaps that was my prayer to God: Why Lord? What does all this mean? What are you asking of me and of my priests? What do you want to see happen among your people? Is this a time of purification or is it nothing more than devastation? Are people going to stop believing, will faithful people stop being people of faith? Lord, what are you asking of us and how can we make it happen?

The questions running through my mind are many and it was in the Blessed Sacrament
Chapel of Our Lady of Fatima Church in Sydney River, where I met privately with Ron Martin, that the Word of God, hanging on a tapestry, said to me, “Be still and know that I am God”. It is this word which I pray all can receive and reflect upon, a word which calms us down in the storm and refocuses our attention, not on failure, disgrace,disappointment and anger – but on the reality of God experienced, if and when we can stop and be still.

It has occurred to me that in these past few days many of us are experiencing the reality
and the full implication of the mystery of our faith. We are personally going through the passion and the death which Christ experienced, but we have not yet gone beyond death to the resurrection. It is as if we are presently sealed up in a dark tomb waiting for the power of the Spirit of God to overtake us and raise us up to a new day and a new future.
It is this Spirit of God, this Holy Spirit, which we must open our hearts to receive – for
only the Holy Spirit can drive out the un-holy spirits with which so many have become obsessed.
Our faith in Jesus Christ is a response from the heart – a heart which has known the
healing grace of mercy and forgiveness. At this time when so many hearts have been broken, we need to know again or for the first time, the healing grace of God’s love. Such healing grace can only come from all of us sharing together our faith and convictions that, in spite of sin in all its forms, mercy is stronger than anger, forgiveness is more powerful than rejection and reconciliation is more transformative of spiritual devastation into new life possibilities.
Because we still are people of faith – let those who can, come together to continue to
proclaim the love of Christ. May we find in our faith the foundation upon which our Church can be re-founded, not to be a perfect society reserved only for the pure, but an assembly of forgiven and resurrected human beings animated by healed and Eucharistic hearts. If our church is to get beyond our present difficulties, if we hope to have any significant future, we must learn the lessons which these last years of struggle point to.

One of these lessons is for all of us to have a better understanding of what constitutes a human person. People,
priests, bishops are human, and failure to see, recognize and care about this will continue to produce inhuman expectations and give rise to inhuman behaviour. Another lesson is that failure in pastoral leadership is also connected to a misunderstanding of the diverse relationships which are needed to hold together the community of faith. Bishops, priests, deacons and lay ministers are not superheroes; leadership among the people of God is not about power, it is about caring.

There are many areas that we must attend to in order to move forward. Some are
immediate, others will take more time. Together, let us face the present crisis; let us find the heart needed to slowly reconstruct our relationships and our capacity to trust and to care. It starts by being still before God and slowly reaches out to another person with love and acceptance. May the God of stillness and the Spirit of life bless all of us and may the person of Jesus Christ be the foundation of our lives.

Sincerely in Christ,

Anthony Mancini
Archbishop of Halifax,
Apostolic Administrator of Yarmouth and
Apostolic Administrator of Antigonish

(I had problems reproducing this letter with the original letterhead and formatting – for this I apologize. Fr. Bob)

5 thoughts on “Letter of Archbishop Mancini

  1. it is very interesting to see reactions from catholics in regard to the bishop lahey case. there is no connection between intelligence and emotional understanding. the classic example is the doctor who sexually abuses his own daughter. many catholics hold their priests in high esteem. in many cases these priests have much more education than their parishoners. people ‘sense’ when they are deceived and know when there is condecension. it is a dissappointment to many to think about there beautiful place of worship crumble to the ground. many catholic church communities are part and parcel of peoples social life. questions are asked -do all catholic priests and nuns who serve priests, look the other way in these cases of child abuse. one u.s. catholic bishop called the police when finding out about a priest in his diocese abusing children. was this a one in a thousand case? people are concerned about all of the 3rd world priests now in canada. abuse in 3rd world countries is rampant especially where there are no lawyers and lots of corrupt judges. abuse ruins lives and there is little more to talk about.


  2. a writer in colorado springs, colorado remarked: what is archbishop mancini saying and what does he mean using this different terminology. with the start of all of the news on bishop lahey you would hear ‘he was so pastoral’ (bishop lahey) there will never be a harmony between the catholic clergy and the catholic laity. women must be clergy to protect children. women must be clergy as they would prohibit men from abusing children. married couples protect their chidren and other children. i do not go to church and all catholic priests believe that i am headed for eternal damnation. these beliefs are destructive. beyong our human reasoning is beyong our realm. for those of us who believe in jesus christ and believe in compassion for all there will always be hope that these catholic priests will learn to respect everyone.


  3. Margaret,
    The tone of your unforgiving words indicates that you’re probably not a Christian. You probably didn’t undertand Archibishop Mancini’s letter. Be still.


  4. Archbishop Mancini,
    Wow! We have great expectations from Bishops and Archbishops and this is causing and will continue to cause inhuman behavior??!! Raping children is NOT ‘human’ behavior, it is intrinsically evil. Maybe we need to ask why your office dropped the ball when you brought us a bishop who was legally exposed in the horrific Mount Cashel Orphanage scandal. Why, Archbishop, didn’t you take notice of your bishop’s trips to Asia? Listen. We, the people who stay, need to ‘up’ the expectations on bishops ‘and’ priests because they are deceiving us and hurting our children, raping little ones and Archbishop, ‘you’ need to do your job!


  5. A great antidote to the handwringing over the agony of those in leadership roles – how about focusing on the victims who were used and abused??

    Cardinal George’s about-to-be-released book “The Difference God Makes” (Crossroad) calls for a less narrow and triumphalistic version of Catholic identity. He points out that there is far too much focus on the bishops – their power and the way they exercise it, and not nearly enough on Christ.

    He maintains that the strain in relationships within the church is due to the walls that have been built which separate us: political, specialized, and individualistic.

    He states that our Catholic identity should come, precisely, from the quality of our relationships with others, at every level in the church, who cannot be ‘un-chosen’. Separations diminish us as a body.

    Cardinal George is at the Vatican this week, and is presenting his book at the Lateran University. He hopes that its global appeal will kindle a greater concern for serving the poor and engaging in prayer. It is his game plan to “evangelize America and beyond”.

    Read more at ncronline.org


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s